Two Parties, One Coup · Episode 5 of 6 · 22 min
How Carter's Human Rights Push Lost Iran
A generation after Truman, another Democrat, Jimmy Carter, pressed the Shah on human rights, and his own advisers split over it. When revolution erupted in 1978 and 1979, the U.S. could not save the monarchy restored in 1953. The Shah fled, Khomeini's Islamic Republic took hold, and the embassy seizure began a 444-day hostage crisis.
Who's who
- Jimmy Carter+12 more episodesDemocratic president who elevated human rights in foreign policy
- Mohammad Reza Pahlavi+8 more episodesYoung Shah of Iran, pressured to sign decrees against Mosaddegh
- Ruhollah Khomeini+3 more episodesExiled cleric who became the figurehead of the Islamic Revolution
- Zbigniew BrzezinskiNational Security Adviser who warned the policy would weaken a vital ally
- Cyrus VanceCarter adviser on the human-rights side of the internal split
- Jeane KirkpatrickConservative critic who later attacked Carter for losing Iran
Where it happens
- Tehran, Iran+7 more episodesSite of the revolution and the seized U.S. embassy
- United States+16 more episodesWhere the ailing Shah was admitted for medical treatment
Timeline
- 1977-1978Carter's human-rights pressure strains the alliance as unrest builds in Iran.
- January 1979The Shah flees and the Islamic Revolution triumphs, ending the monarchy.
- November 4, 1979Militants seize the U.S. embassy after the Shah is admitted to the U.S.; the 444-day hostage crisis begins.
Still debated
Critics such as Kirkpatrick argued Carter's human-rights emphasis helped lose a key ally, while others see it as a principled stand. Whether prioritizing human rights abroad is naive or wise remains an open argument.
← PreviousHow Oil Money Built the Shah's Secret PoliceNext →The 1953 Iran Coup: Myth vs. What Really Happened
Connected episodes in other series
444 Days: The Iran Hostage Crisis and How It Was WeaponizedIran & America: A Century and Counting · Episode 4Also features Jimmy Carter, Mohammad Reza Pahlavi
Torrijos: How a General Talked America Into Giving the Canal BackPanama: Crossroads of Empires · Episode 13Also features Jimmy Carter
Jerry Falwell, Pat Robertson, and the Rise of the Moral MajorityA Wall of Separation · Episode 9Also features Jimmy Carter
The Lottery and the End: The Botched Draw and the Draft's Last DaysGreeting: America and the Draft · Episode 11Also features Jimmy Carter