After the November 1952 election, an Eisenhower administration committed to anti-communist containment reached the opposite decision from Truman's. British intelligence stressed the risk of a Tudeh takeover, though analysts privately doubted it, and Washington approved a covert plan to pressure the Shah into dismissing Mosaddegh. Historians still debate whether oil or communism was the main driver.
Historians divide over whether the dominant U.S. motive was anti-communism or control of oil; both were present and their relative weight is disputed. Some also note that analysts privately doubted any real Soviet threat.



