One of the largest human-made excavations on Earth sits above a 72-square-mile plume of contaminated groundwater, and its owner avoided a Superfund listing. The episode tells how Kennecott Utah Copper and regulators used a 1995 agreement, the model for the Superfund Alternative Approach, to keep Bingham Canyon off the National Priorities List, and weighs what that meant.
Who's who
Daniel C. JacklingMining engineer who pioneered large-scale open-pit copper mining at Bingham
1986Utah files natural-resource-damage claim against Kennecott
1994EPA proposes listing the South Zone on the National Priorities List
1995EPA, Utah, and Kennecott agree to postpone listing in favor of a company cleanup
2006Bingham Canyon Water Treatment Plant begins producing culinary-quality water
April 10, 2013Rock avalanches send about 145 million tons of waste rock into the pit
Still debated
Whether the 1995 deal served the public or the company is a genuine policy trade-off. Kennecott's share of valley air pollution and Clean Air Act compliance are disputed, and the endpoint of the groundwater cleanup is open.