← Can You Hear Me Now
Can You Hear Me Now cover
Can You Hear Me Now · Episode 1 of 14 · 22 min

Fire on the Hill

A beacon fire can say only what both ends agreed in advance, a limit the Greek historian Polybius named and information theory later called one bit. The episode follows fire and smoke signals from Greek, Byzantine and Korean chains to Apache and Lakota smoke, then to the Congo drummers who made a drum speak. It also weighs the objection that none of this counts as telecommunication.

Who's who

  • AeschylusAthenian playwright whose Agamemnon opens with a watchman awaiting a beacon
  • PolybiusGreek historian who explained why beacons cannot report the unexpected
  • Leo the MathematicianByzantine scholar credited with the ninth-century beacon line to Constantinople
  • Lucas McMahonHistorian who used terrain modeling to argue the Byzantine chain could work
  • Garrick MalleryArmy ethnologist whose 1881 report collected smoke-signal accounts
  • John F. CarringtonMissionary-linguist who documented Congo basin talking drums
  • Claude Shannon+1 more episodeBell Labs mathematician who used the word bit in 1948
  • Édouard EstauniéFrench telegraph engineer who coined the word telecommunication in 1904

Where it happens

Timeline

  1. 458 B.C.Aeschylus's Oresteia, with its beacon speech, wins first prize in Athens
  2. Second century B.C.Polybius critiques beacons and sets out a five-by-five torch alphabet
  3. 829 to 842Reign of Theophilos, when the Byzantine beacon line is usually placed
  4. 1588Beacons are lit along the English coast as the Spanish Armada is sighted
  5. 1904Édouard Estaunié coins the word telecommunication
  6. May 8, 2025White smoke from the Sistine Chapel announces the election of Pope Leo XIV

Still debated

Scholars question whether the beacon chain in Agamemnon was real and whether the Byzantine line worked as later sources say. The story of King You's false beacons is treated as legend, and how the talking drums should be classed remains open.

beaconssmoke signalssignalingtalking drumsinformation theoryancient greece